Model Train Forum banner
1 - 10 of 10 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
14 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Hey y’all so I am stuck at a crossing. So I have and I want to stick with HO scale and I currently have Bachmann Loco’s. I don’t know if I want to switch from Bachman to MTH or Lionel or both of those two. Like which one it better,more affordable (mind you I’m 14) and I’m saving my money up for a DCC controller and a DCC engine that’s Bachman. So please help I don’t know what to do. Thanks.
 

· Premium Member
HO 1950s SP in So. Cal.
Joined
·
2,774 Posts
There are many good manufactures of DCC locomotives out there.
All are good quality and good runners.
The biggest difference in price is in the amount of detail on the loco.
Bachmann locos run good but lack detail, not a bad buy if you're not interested in
highly detailed locos.
Athearn, BLI, Walthers, etc. have more detail but cost more.
What Lehigh74 said about MTH.

Magic
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,678 Posts
If you check with your local train shops I'm sure you'll find one capable of installing DCC chips.
Or buy a soldering iron, some 1/16" and 1/8" heat shrink tubing, learn for yourself! It's really not that complicated, you just need to pay attention to what you're doing.
Here's a YouTube channel with a lot of installs:

You can DO this!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
12,871 Posts
Model railroading isn't like a game console. You don't have to chose between compatable systems and then buy only things made for that system.

HO (and every other size) is a scale, that is, a proportional (in this case, 1/87th) representation of the real thing. Everything sold as HO scale should be manufactured to standards, and should be compatible together, within reason.

Now, this isn't totally true. Different codes of track require some effort to join, different brands of "roadbed" track need some major surgery to join to other brands, and some longer equipment won't operate properly on tight curves and turnouts, but in general, just because you have Bachmann, or Kato, or Atlas, or whatever track doesn't mean you can't run locos and cars from other manufacturers on it, nor does it mean you have to get a DCC system, or decoders, made by that same company (for DCC, the power supply, base station, and throttles must be from the same company, but decoders, circuit breakers, boosters, reverse loop controllers etc., don't have to be).

I have track pieces from MicroEngineering, Atlas, and Walthers on my layout, and locos / rolling stock from Atlas, Accurail, Athearn, Bachmann, Bowser, Exactrail, IHC / Mehano, Rapido, Stewart, and Walthers (and probably some others that I'm forgetting). If you add roadbed, structures, non-train vehicles, and scenery materials, the list of what I am using grows exponentially. All of it in HO scale and all of it interoperable.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,546 Posts
A dcc controller (the control box, handheld controller, or wifi controller) doesn't care WHO made the engine. All that's important is that the engine has a dcc decoder inside and that you have the right engine number dialed into it.

Just buy the engine you like, but make sure it has a socket for a dcc decoder (or perhaps it may have dcc pre-installed). Some have 8 pin sockets, some have 21 pin sockets.

Be careful with MTH engines.
MTH has its own control system called "dcs". This isn't the same as "dcc".
dcs engines can run on dcc systems, but they can be cranky.

Some MTH engines come WITHOUT dcs, they are just plain old "DC" but also have an 8-pin socket so you can put a dcc decoder in them, too.
If I was buying an MTH engine, this is what I'd look for.

It's not hard to install a decoder into an engine that has a socket for dcc already there. Usually the hardest part is getting the shell off and back on.

You have to be careful about the size and type of decoder you buy. Make sure it will fit!
 
1 - 10 of 10 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top