Model Train Forum banner

New 4-6-2 coming from American Models.

593 Views 26 Replies 4 Participants Last post by  AmFlyer
6
Back in Mid-April I ordered some parts from American Models. Since I live in Jackson MI, and they’re located in Whitmore Lake- which is about 45-60 minutes from me, depending on highways or the scenic route-I opted to pick up my order.
They mentioned they had something new in the works . The gentleman who assisted me showed me a number of things I hadn’t seen and then this little gem:








he described it as a “4-6-2 with a Vandy Tender”. I asked about price, he said between $600 and $800. He said it was different than the USRA Heavy they made previously.
He didn’t give me a date on release , but soon. Seems Ron Bashista had been working on it when he died.
I don’t recognize the prototype, but I like it. I want one.
See less See more
1 - 20 of 27 Posts
That engine variant has been in development for two years. It also has a revised cab. I hope it hits the catalog soon. When I last talked to them I asked about another run of the streamlined Hudson. They said it was under consideration but no decision yet made.
That engine variant has been in development for two years. It also has a revised cab. I hope it hits the catalog soon. When I last talked to them I asked about another run of the streamlined Hudson. They said it was under consideration but no decision yet made.
What specifics do you have on it?

I have the streamlined Hudson. Smooth and sharp looking runner. But I also have the streamlined Pennsy K-4S. Ditto.
At one time the Pacific with the Vandy tender was featured on the AM website as an upcoming release. All I know is from the description that AM had posted. As far as I know, if the Hudson is rerun, the changes would be minimal to none.
3
It's been a long time coming. AM first announced the improved 4-6-2 at the 2018 Fall S-Fest:



I somehow doubt the 2018 prices will be valid, though. Ron also mentioned at the time the Pacific would also be available with the standard tender. That too may have changed.

Rusty
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
It's been a long time coming. AM first announced the improved 4-6-2 at the 2018 Fall S-Fest:

View attachment 604825 View attachment 604826 View attachment 604827

I somehow doubt the 2018 prices will be valid, though. Ron also mentioned at the time the Pacific would also be available with the standard tender. That too may have changed.

Rusty
I was told $600 to $800
One thing I would hope AM corrects on the new 4-6-2 is the location of the main rod on the crosshead. Since the beginning, the main rod is secured on the outside of the crosshead. It should be on the inside. The crosshead part is actually designed to have the main rod on the inside.

If not, well it's a pretty easy thing to change. After removing the rod and valve gear assembly, carefully punch out the rivet, move the rod to the inside, reuse the rivet and flare it over with a center punch. I've done this to my four AM 4-6-2s, both scale and hirail. It doesn't affect operation one bit.

Rusty
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
What is the consensus? Wait for the AM? Or get the AF Legacy?
2
What is the consensus? Wait for the AM? Or get the AF Legacy?
The answer is: It depends. If your running AC or Legacy, without a doubt the Lionel/Flyer Pacific at $699.99 is the better value, even before discounting. You'd be hard pressed to find the AM Pacific at a discount.

However if your looking for Scale operation, the AM model is "it" as there are no scale wheel conversions for the Lionel/Flyer Pacifics.

Detail wise, the Lionel/Flyer Pacific wins hands down. It is a very good representation of a USRA light Pacific. This is the TMCC version from 2007:




The AM Pacific is almost Mantua-like (HO) with its minimal detail. However, the AM model is a good "blank slate" for detailing if one so desires.



That said, at $600 for the projected price for the (I assume conventional DC) AM model seems a little high. But I guess you have to put it in perspective, it's not 2008 anymore when the DC model sold for $300.. I don't think even Lionel would be able to maintain the current $699.99 asking price if they do a following run of Pacifics or Mikados.

And of course, AM doesn't offer a command version and the TMCC/Legacy sounds are far superior to the Ott (last I heard) sound board AM uses.

Rusty
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 2
The answer is: It depends. If your running AC or Legacy, without a doubt the Lionel/Flyer Pacific at $699.99 is the better value, even before discounting. You'd be hard pressed to find the AM Pacific at a discount.

However if your looking for Scale operation, the AM model is "it" as there are no scale wheel conversions for the Lionel/Flyer Pacifics.

Detail wise, the Lionel/Flyer Pacific wins hands down. It is a very good representation of a USRA light Pacific. This is the TMCC version from 2007:

View attachment 604842


The AM Pacific is almost Mantua-like (HO) with its minimal detail. However, the AM model is a good "blank slate" for detailing if one so desires.

View attachment 604841

That said, at $600 for the projected price for the (I assume conventional DC) AM model seems a little high. But I guess you have to put it in perspective, it's not 2008 anymore when the DC model sold for $300.. I don't think even Lionel would be able to maintain the current $699.99 asking price if they do a following run of Pacifics or Mikados.

And of course, AM doesn't offer a command version and the TMCC/Legacy sounds are far superior to the Ott (last I heard) sound board AM uses.

Rusty
I typically run AC or Flyerchief . I have run my Flyerchief Berkshire on AC and on DC.
4
To add to what Rusty said, the Legacy Pacific is far more detailed plus has fan driven smoke, an electrocoupler, operating classification lights, outstanding quality sounds and communicates with Sensor Tracks for operation control as well as programming. Legacy engines also run on DCC. When Scale Trains releases their S gauge engines (several years out?) they will be DCC so being able to use their engines and Legacy with the same controller will be nice.
The best running engines on conventional power are Legacy engines. They have excellent speed control, can creep along when needed and most sounds are available with just the whistle and bell buttons. I bought three of the new Legacy Pacifics for $630 each, Santa Fe, NYC and Great Northern.
I think $600+ for a new AM Pacific is not competitive when it has no electronics in it. Under the shell it is basically an updated Gilbert engine with a piston driven chugger and smoke unit. AM makes the best available Northern but I spent another $450 to have mine converted to run on Legacy with a fan driven smoke unit, Railsounds and electrocoupler.

Pictures of the three Pacifics.

See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 3
2
In defense of the AM Pacific, as I've stated above it's a good blank slate for detailing. The other saving grace of the AM Pacific is they run beautifully. This one will eventually become a Santa Fe locomotive of a fictional 3601 class:



Right now, it's currently on a very crowded back burner.

And here's the other side of my redetailed Pacific done in 1998:



As for the upcoming offering: The jury's out. While I have some ideas, I need another locomotive project like I need a hole in my head. (Just where is my drill, anyway?:eek: )

Rusty
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
To add to what Rusty said, the Legacy Pacific is far more detailed plus has fan driven smoke, an electrocoupler, operating classification lights, outstanding quality sounds and communicates with Sensor Tracks for operation control as well as programming. Legacy engines also run on DCC. When Scale Trains releases their S gauge engines (several years out?) they will be DCC so being able to use their engines and Legacy with the same controller will be nice.
The best running engines on conventional power are Legacy engines. They have excellent speed control, can creep along when needed and most sounds are available with just the whistle and bell buttons. I bought three of the new Legacy Pacifics for $630 each, Santa Fe, NYC and Great Northern.
I think $600+ for a new AM Pacific is not competitive when it has no electronics in it. Under the shell it is basically an updated Gilbert engine with a piston driven chugger and smoke unit. AM makes the best available Northern but I spent another $450 to have mine converted to run on Legacy with a fan driven smoke unit, Railsounds and electrocoupler.

Pictures of the three Pacifics.

View attachment 604844 View attachment 604845 View attachment 604846 View attachment 604847
I thought AM stuff ran smoother than the old Gilbert and smoother than the Lionel made stuff from the late 80s and 90s.
Rusty, you always have great ideas for how to improve your engines. They look great. I simply do not have that ability, or interest, to modify and detail engines.
Jack, AM engines have good gearing with can motors and run better than Gilbert engines. The difference is greater with diesels than with steam engines. Early Lionel engines did not run well either. Legacy engines are a completely different matter. The first command control S gauge engines were made in 2005, the Pacific and Mikado TMCC models. They are highly detailed they have 100 speed steps, momentum and braking. I have six of them. In 2008 Lionel released Big Boy 4014 in S gauge with full Legacy, 200 absolute (not relative) speed steps. It is big, but a few K-Line S gauge boxcars behind it and it looks perfect. Run 4014 on a layout with a Legacy Cab2 handheld to see how good command control can be is S gauge.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
Rusty, you always have great ideas for how to improve your engines. They look great. I simply do not have that ability, or interest, to modify and detail engines.
Jack, AM engines have good gearing with can motors and run better than Gilbert engines. The difference is greater with diesels than with steam engines. Early Lionel engines did not run well either. Legacy engines are a completely different matter. The first command control S gauge engines were made in 2005, the Pacific and Mikado TMCC models. They are highly detailed they have 100 speed steps, momentum and braking. I have six of them. In 2008 Lionel released Big Boy 4014 in S gauge with full Legacy, 200 absolute (not relative) speed steps. It is big, but a few K-Line S gauge boxcars behind it and it looks perfect. Run 4014 on a layout with a Legacy Cab2 handheld to see how good command control can be is S gauge.
I sold my early Lionel locos. Kept my rolling stock.
How does Flyerchief compare to Legacy? I’ve got the Flyerchief PM 1225 Berkshire. She’s smooth, the momentum thing is very cool. Sounds are good.
At this point, I’m thinking of sticking to Flyerchief/Legacy for steam , AM for conventional diesels . I don’t like Flyerchief diesel price tags.
2
The newest FlyerChief engines with BT are pretty nice. Legacy engines are a step above in details, electronics and features, performance and price. Some engines are made in both configurations, some are only FlyerChief and some are only Legacy.
Here are some pictures of the first release Legacy Y3's and the latest release with whistle steam added. The two small slots in the track in front of the uncoupler is a Sensor Track for issuing preset commands to Legacy engines at that point on the layout.

See less See more
In defense of the AM Pacific, as I've stated above it's a good blank slate for detailing. The other saving grace of the AM Pacific is they run beautifully. This one will eventually become a Santa Fe locomotive of a fictional 3601 class:

View attachment 604850

Right now, it's currently on a very crowded back burner.

And here's the other side of my redetailed Pacific done in 1998:

View attachment 604852

As for the upcoming offering: The jury's out. While I have some ideas, I need another locomotive project like I need a hole in my head. (Just where is my drill, anyway?:eek: )

Rusty
Interesting job. That a freelanced/fictional railroad? What’s the story on it?
3
Interesting job. That a freelanced/fictional railroad? What’s the story on it?
Yes, the Seattle Tacoma and Portland is a fictional railroad. It's but one of several fictitious railroads I've done. I came up with the ST&P in the mid-1970's when I was in HO. It actually was a little earlier when it was just initials without a name. I though I could use STP oil decals for a herald. I put them on one locomotive and it looked just plain silly. I eventually came up with a triangular herald and had Miller Engineering run decals in yellow and white so I could do both steam and diesel. The Pacific is the only ST&P S Scale steam locomotive, although there are four steamers in HO. After Miller gave up the custom deal business, I had Rail Graphics make decals suitable for S Scale.

I've also done a pair of FP7's and a GP9 in S plus a handfull of freight cars:





The ST&P is in "retirement." The new railroad will have a new name.

Rusty
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Yes, the Seattle Tacoma and Portland is a fictional railroad. It's but one of several fictitious railroads I've done. I came up with the ST&P in the mid-1970's when I was in HO. It actually was a little earlier when it was just initials without a name. I though I could use STP oil decals for a herald. I put them on one locomotive and it looked just plain silly. I eventually came up with a triangular herald and had Miller Engineering run decals in yellow and white so I could do both steam and diesel. The Pacific is the only ST&P S Scale steam locomotive, although there are four steamers in HO. After Miller gave up the custom deal business, I had Rail Graphics make decals suitable for S Scale.

I've also done a pair of FP7's and a GP9 in S plus a handfull of freight cars:

View attachment 604882
View attachment 604884
View attachment 604885

The ST&P is in "retirement." The new railroad will have a new name.

Rusty
I like it. It’s different. Plus you get to decide what is used. No prototype to be judged against.
Yes, the Seattle Tacoma and Portland is a fictional railroad. It's but one of several fictitious railroads I've done. I came up with the ST&P in the mid-1970's when I was in HO. It actually was a little earlier when it was just initials without a name. I though I could use STP oil decals for a herald. I put them on one locomotive and it looked just plain silly. I eventually came up with a triangular herald and had Miller Engineering run decals in yellow and white so I could do both steam and diesel. The Pacific is the only ST&P S Scale steam locomotive, although there are four steamers in HO. After Miller gave up the custom deal business, I had Rail Graphics make decals suitable for S Scale.

I've also done a pair of FP7's and a GP9 in S plus a handfull of freight cars:

View attachment 604882
View attachment 604884
View attachment 604885

The ST&P is in "retirement." The new railroad will have a new name.

Rusty
Any other pics of the layout? I’m impressed.
1 - 20 of 27 Posts
Top