Model Train Forum banner

Size comparison of scales

114K views 140 replies 67 participants last post by  DanielC  
#1 ·
I adapted this picture I found on another site and thought it might be useful to people trying to decide what kind of train they want.

Image
 

Attachments

#107 ·
“Real” HO scale cars are indeed HO scale….I presume you are talking about those slot cars that were marketed as HO….they were not, and never were, HO scale….more like S scale (1/64)….they bastardized the scale….
Image
 
  • Like
Reactions: madkm
#109 ·
Maybe a case of some confusion about “scale” vs “gauge”….they are not the same thing, but are used interchangeably by many….
 
#112 ·
Lionel always had different size cars even in prewar with the 800 and 600 series. The 800 was so much larger. the couplers would not meet a 600 series car. In postwar the cars could couple but you would see a height, length, and width difference. Most of my rolling stock is 027 compatible. When the length hangs over on the curves it is time to go to O gage track. I will say the 027 rolling stock is close to S scale. My MKT 600 switcher would navigate 027 it was not something I would do to enjoy. I do have both on my table.
 
#118 ·
It this the discussion between gage and scale? The original picture was posted by the op but he is not the maker.
027 may not be a scale but it does have a scale associated to it. Just compare an O gage car to an 027 car.
When I first started collected I never thought about the size of cars until I ran into an O gage car. It was so much larger but still not a true O scale car.. guess it really was the scale of the cars I noticed. After thinking about it I noticed an 027 car is close to an S scale car.
 
#121 ·
no, you cant ride them, they range in scale from 1/32 scale to 1/20th scale , in the past 40 plus years, but historically modelers have built layouts in their gardens in all the scales back to the first wind up trains, Todays Garden trains Are powered with traditional transformers, batteries and Radio control or even live steam.
 
#129 ·
The next step above was historically called 1 Gauge not G, and was in the rage of 1/32 scale here in the US . Way back when this formula was put in place there was no G ! The same issue in o gauge . its not o it was 0 ( Zero Gauge) , H0 ( Half Zero ) ect. This ,at the time, also was meant to Standardize track gauges for the Toy Train industry at the time and little to do with scale.